I love this book, this is by far the best warriors book i have ever read.

So good yet sad! :(

This is my most favourite WARRIORS book! Love the plot!

Amazing book, I'm liking Riverclan's point of view, Thunderclan has been used so much it's becoming sorta messed up. *Flameblaze, First of all, Crookedstar is female, and Goosfeather did nothing wrong, he's Starclan.

a truly awesome book. SPOILER ALERT! Crookedstar was fooled! She believed Mapleshade was a StarClan warrior. She is actually a Dark Forest Warrior! Is Goosefeather a StarClan warrior or a Dark Forest warrior? He didn't seem to be so bad when I read Bluestar's Prophency.

I can't wait for Yellowfang's Secret!! (newest super edition book but not coming out any time soon. Maybe in December or next year?

best warriors book ever!!

Great book!! Love RiverClan's point of view! (Haha...fishbrain instead of mousebrain) SPOILERS!! This super edition goes through the life of Crookedstar. He was born in a terrible storm, sheltered by a giant oak so his mother originally named him Stormkit and his brother Oakkit. After an accident, his jaw got permanently twisted. His mother, Rainflower, pretty much abandoned him because he was no longer her handsome little warrior. She then asked Hailstar to rename him Crookedkit with no conversation with Shellheart, her mate. Due to his jaw, his apprenticeship was about a moon late. With his brother in the apprentice's den and his mother back to normal warrior duties, he was all alone in the nursery. After he got apprenticed, he met a strange cat in his dreams. Her name was Mapleshade who tells him she can make him the best warrior if he made one promise, to be loyal to his clan, above all else. He agrees. Crookedpaw goes out with few warriors on a patrol. He spots a dog headed for Willowpaw, so he chases the dog away from her. Willowpaw loves Crookedpaw for saving her life. He is then made warrior (Crookedjaw) for his heroism. Later on, Willowbreeze is captured by Twolegs and Crookedjaw runs back to camp to get help. Hailstar says she'll be okay until the next morning and he'll send a patrol to save her then. Crookedjaw sneaks out at night to save Willowbreeze. Mapleshade says he can't love Willowbreeze because of his promise, but he doesn't care. That night he goes on a walk with her and confesses his love. He becomes deputy when his father moves to the elder's den and shortly after, leader. Shellheart dies because of an infection. Willowbreeze is expecting his kits. The morning after her kitting, Crookedstar goes in to see his mate and kits. They name the three and Willowbreeze then tells him how much she loves him and how she'll miss him. Crookedstar is the devastated when she and two of their three kits die. He sort of rejects Silverkit because she's the only cat he loves that is still alive. Oakheart points out that he's still there and persuades him to be more fatherly to her and he does. END OF SPOILERS!!

This book was AMAZING! I had no idea how crookedstar's background life was so harsh and so sad. Poor Crookedstar! This is the best book out of all the super edition warrior books! once more, poor crookedstar! had to endure so much pain and loss in his life. :(

i love warriors xD . im 41st in line =(. Ha ha now im -41 in line =^.^= catmeow